|
|
||||||||
School of Biological Sciences, Ashworth Laboratories, University of Edinburgh, Kings Buildings, West Mains Road, Edinburgh, United Kingdom, EH9 3JT
1 Corresponding author: o.m.onyiro{at}sms.ed.ac.uk
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Key Words: genetic analysis locomotion conformation housing system
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Environmental variability in locomotion traits is associated with differences in management and housing systems (Broom, 1990; Esslemont, 1990). Bergsten (2004) reported that floors in intensive farming systems are mostly made of nonyielding concrete, which gets slippery over time, and manure contamination is widespread; the result of this is increased locomotion disorders. Studies have reported an increased prevalence of hoof lesions with solid concrete floors compared with straw yards (Webster, 2002; Somers et al., 2003). Similar results were observed with solid concrete floors vs. slatted concrete floors (Frankena et al., 1992) and solid concrete floors vs. rubber slats (Hultgren and Bergsten, 2001). In the United Kingdom, information on housing type and flooring quality is routinely collected at the same time the cows are type-classified, providing the opportunity to estimate associations among type traits and housing by using national data.
On the basis of genetic correlations of clinical lameness with type traits, Boettcher et al. (1998) suggested that foot angle, rear leg set, and rump width could provide an indication of susceptibility to locomotion problems. Old age, deep udders, sickled legs, and long hoof diagonals have also been associated with locomotion problems in cows (Boelling and Pollot, 1998).
Several studies have estimated genetic parameters for locomotion traits for inclusion into lifetime economic merit indices (Weigel et al., 1998; Stott et al., 2005). In the United Kingdom, recording of type traits dates back more than 20 yr, and a trait describing the locomotion of animals was introduced 10 yr ago. Although estimates of heritabilities and genetic correlations among linear and miscellaneous type traits (Brotherstone et al., 1990), as well as among type and production traits (Brotherstone, 1994), have been reported for UK Holstein-Friesian cows, as yet no genetic associations of locomotion with other type traits have been published. Bone quality (BONEQ) is a new trait in the UK type classification scheme and is not routinely classified in many other countries. As a result, little information is available in the literature on the genetic and phenotypic relationships of BONEQ with other type traits, in particular type traits associated with longevity. Bone quality is measured on a linear scale from thick and coarse bone to flat and refined bone. Gordon and Shannon (2002) reported that BONEQ is an indication of fitness and good circulation through the legs and has a strong positive genetic correlation with dairy character and milk production. Flat- and fine-boned cows will walk better as a result of decreased bone mass and reduced surface area of contact, particularly at the hock joints, which could minimize leg problems. Dekkers et al. (1994) reported that BONEQ had a moderate genetic association with longevity.
The aims of this research were 1) to determine the influence of housing system on linear and composite type traits related to lameness in Holstein-Friesian dairy cows, 2) to estimate the heritability of locomotion and its genetic correlation with other traits related to legs and feet, and 3) to investigate whether BONEQ is a useful type trait to collect, particularly with respect to its genetic association with locomotive problems.
| MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The type traits involved in the analysis were the linear traits locomotion score (LOCO), rear leg, side view (RLS), and foot angle (FA), the overall subjective type traits legs and feet (L&F) and mammary composite (MAMM), and BONEQ. Mammary composite, which is highly correlated with linear traits describing udder conformation, was included because many of the udder traits have been shown to be associated with clinical lameness (Boettcher et al., 1998). The linear traits are scored from 1 to 9, where 1 and 9 represent biological extremes, and the composite traits are scored from 65 to 95, which represents a continuum on a scale from "poor" to "excellent." A brief description of the traits is given in Table 1
, whereas the locomotion scoring system used for the national herds is defined in Table 2
.
|
|
Housing Information
Three pieces of housing information were routinely collected by the field officers: 1) Housing type—cows were recorded as being housed in 1 of 4 different categories of housing: cubicles, straw yards, on pasture, and others (slatted and loafing yards). 2) Time spent in housing—the amount of time the animal had spent in a particular type of housing was recorded. This allowed us to differentiate between (for example) an animal that had spent a month on pasture and one that had been on pasture for 4 mo. 3) Floor condition at classification—the condition of the farm flooring on which the type classification took place was graded from 1 to 5, depending on how slippery and even the flooring was. A poor flooring condition (floor 1) was characterized by slippery, dirty surfaces and holes in the concrete, whereas the ideal condition (floor 5) denoted nonslippery, clean, and level surfaces. Although this assessment was based on the floor where the cows were classified, we would expect this floor condition to be related to the floor condition on all parts of the farm and also to be related to the overall management of the dairy. Evaluation of the flooring by scorers was subjective. The numbers of cows scored on floor conditions 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5 were 25,284, 4,894, 15,408, 32,491, and 78,693, respectively.
Statistical Analysis
Analysis was by univariate REML, using an animal model. The pedigree file comprised 309,881 animals. Because of the small number of animals spending 6 or more months in a particular type of housing, the amount of time in a particular housing type was reclassified as 1, 2, 3, 4, or 5 mo and then 6 or more. Similarly, few animals were recorded in slatted or loafing yards, so no account of the amount of time in this housing type was made. The total numbers of cows classified in cubicles, straw yards, on pasture, and in slatted or loafing yards were 97,511, 8,535, 49,655, and 1,069, respectively. A preliminary analysis indicated that housing type, month in housing, and their interaction removed a significant amount of variation in the type traits, so in the final model, months in housing was nested within housing type. We will refer to this combined effect as the housing situation. Herd-year-visit was included as a random effect because it was confounded with floor condition.
The mixed-model equation used to describe the data is
![]() |
where Yi is the type trait measurement on animal i, µ is the overall mean, hyv is the herd-year-visit group where animal i was measured,
1 and
2 are the linear and quadratic regression coefficients of traits on the age of animal i at inspection, β1 and β2 are the linear and quadratic regression coefficients of traits on stage of lactation (stage) of animal i at inspection,
is the linear regression of traits on the proportion of Holstein genes (phols) in the animal, moc is the month of calving of the animal, hfloor is the floor condition when animal i was inspected, hcode.hmns is the housing situation (type of housing and time spent in each type of housing), animi is the random genetic effect of the animal, and ei is the residual random error.
To account for differences in the range of scoring used by the field officers, each trait was first scaled by the ratio of the standard deviation of the classifier to the mean standard deviation of all classifiers (Brotherstone, 1994). Heritability for each trait was calculated from cow and residual variance components.
Estimation of genetic correlations between BONEQ, LOCO, and the other traits was by multiple-trait REML in an animal model. For computing convenience, the analysis involved a subset of the original data comprising 37,065 type classification records of cows type-classified from the beginning of 2005. Even with the reduced data set, a multivariate analysis with all 6 traits was not possible because of computing difficulties, so 2-trait analyses (i.e., 9 bivariate analyses in total) were performed with BONEQ and each of the other 5 traits in turn, as well as with LOCO and each of the 4 remaining traits. All analyses were carried out by using ASREML software (Gilmour et al., 2000).
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
|
Phenotypic correlations of LOCO with the type traits were generally positive and lower in magnitude than the corresponding genetic relationships. Locomotion score had moderate genetic correlations with FA and MAMM, suggesting that steeper FA and well-fitted mammary systems are associated with better locomotion. Locomotion score and L&F were highly genetically (0.98) and phenotypically (0.78) correlated. A similar result has been found by other researchers (S. Brotherstone, unpublished data; van der Waaij et al., 2005). The genetic association between LOCO and RLS was negative, which indicates that sickled hocks are associated with poorer locomotion.
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Our results show that, in general, cows on pasture had higher linear scores and better composite scores compared with cows in other housing systems. Studies have reported reduced claw disorders in cows on pasture compared with cows in other housing systems (Frankena et al., 1991; Somers et al., 2003). In small-scale Kenyan herds, Gitau et al. (1996) found that cows with access to grazing had a reduced risk of lameness compared with those with no access to grazing. The better L&F and fewer locomotive problems found in cows on grass could be attributed to the fact that grass is a softer environment for lying and rising. This continues to underline the importance of softer housing environments for reducing the incidence of claw and locomotion problems. Fregonesi (1999) showed that dairy cows preferred standing on soft surfaces (straw yards) rather than on concrete floors (cubicle systems). Results obtained from the analysis of flooring condition (Table 4
) indicate that well-managed, nonslippery, and level floor surfaces minimize locomotion disorders.
Genetic Analysis
Heritability.
The type traits associated with L&F had genetic components of variation significantly greater than zero and were low to moderately heritable. In general, the heritability of LOCO (h2 = 0.11) is in agreement with previous estimates (h2 = 0.10) for Holstein-Friesian dairy cows (Stott et al., 2005; van der Waaij et al., 2005). Heritabilities for RLS, FA, and L& F were slightly lower than earlier reports. With a sire model, Brotherstone (1994) obtained heritability estimates of 0.19, 0.27, and 0.32, whereas van der Waaij et al. (2005) reported estimates of 0.22, 0.18, and 0.24, respectively, for the traits. The heritabilities of BONEQ and L&F in our study are consistent with the results of Fatehi et al. (2003), who reported a range of 0.24 to 0.29 for BONEQ and 0.15 to 0.17 for L&F in free-stall vs. tie-stall environments. Van Dorp et al. (2004), in a study of the genetics of locomotion, estimated a heritability of 0.30 for BONEQ in Canadian Holsteins. Our heritability estimate for BONEQ (0.23) suggests that direct selection for flat and refined bone in dairy cows could be moderately successful.
Correlations of BONEQ with Linear and Composite Traits.
Results from the multivariate analysis indicate moderate genetic associations between BONEQ and both LOCO and L&F. This is not surprising because these traits describe a general assessment of the L&F. The results indicate that selection for good mobility, good L&F, or both would lead to improvement in BONEQ and vice versa. According to Rogers (1996), selecting for improved BONEQ may be useful for improving leg traits. Van Dorp et al. (2004) estimated a moderate genetic correlation of 0.25 between BONEQ and locomotion and reported that BONEQ might be affected by poorly designed stalls. In an analysis of QTL affecting lameness and leg conformation traits, Buitenhuis et al. (2007) reported a moderate genetic correlation (–0.49) between lameness and BONEQ in Danish Holstein dairy cattle and concluded that lameness could be reduced by increasing the frequency of the superior QTL genotype for BONEQ. Our result is in agreement with the result of this genomic study showing that locomotion could be improved by selecting for improved BONEQ.
The estimated genetic correlation of 0.30 between BONEQ and MAMM suggests that cows with flat and refined bones are more likely to have well-attached and rounded udders.
Considering the moderate heritability estimate of BONEQ and its high genetic association with LOCO, breeding for flatter, more refined BONEQ seems a promising method of reducing locomotion problems and thereby increasing dairy cow longevity. In the United Kingdom, an index of 3 type traits—foreudder attachment, L&F composite, and MAMM—is used together with SCC in a phenotypic prediction of longevity, and is included in the national genetic evaluations for longevity as a correlated trait (Brotherstone et al., 1998). Including BONEQ in this index may improve its accuracy. However, an investigation to estimate the association of BONEQ with longevity is needed.
No significant genetic relationship was found between BONEQ and both RLS and FA. This is surprising because FA and RLS had moderate genetic correlations with LOCO, which had a high genetic association with BONEQ. A possible explanation is the existence of a nonlinear relationship between these traits. To investigate this, residuals for FA and RLS were regressed on residuals for BONEQ. The results (not shown) indicated a significant linear but nonsignificant quadratic association between BONEQ and the 2 traits.
The phenotypic correlations between BONEQ and LOCO, FA, L&F, and MAMM imply that, phenotypically, cows with fewer locomotive problems, a steeper FA, a high L&F score, and a superior mammary system had flatter, more refined bones.
Correlations Between LOCO and the Other Traits.
The moderate genetic associations of LOCO with FA and MAMM imply that cows with low FA and sagging or pendulous udders are most likely to suffer lameness. Boettcher et al. (1998) obtained strong but negative genetic correlations between FA and clinical lameness from linear (–0.76) and threshold (–0.64) models, and concluded that a flatter FA is genetically associated with increased clinical lameness. The negative genetic correlation between locomotion and RLS suggests that cows with a straight leg set will have improved walking ability.
The tight genetic relationship between LOCO and L&F strongly suggests that the same genes control both traits. Thus, sound locomotion is closely associated with good L&F. Paget et al. (2003) reported a high genetic correlation of 0.91 between locomotion and the L&F composite for UK Guernseys. In the Netherlands, van der Waaij et al. (2005) reported a genetic and phenotypic correlation of 0.98 and 0.85, respectively, between LOCO and L&F for Dutch Holstein-Friesian dairy cows. Classifiers consider mobility while evaluating L&F, so a high genetic association between the 2 traits is expected.
The negative phenotypic correlation between LOCO and RLS indicates that, phenotypically, cows with good locomotion have straighter legs. The associations between LOCO and FA and MAMM suggest that cows with steeper FA and better mammary systems are phenotypically predisposed to better locomotion. Phenotypically, the strong association of LOCO with L&F is evidence that cows with good L&F scores had better mobility.
| CONCLUSIONS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Received for publication July 10, 2007. Accepted for publication September 21, 2007.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
L. G. Baird, N. E. O'Connell, M. A. McCoy, T. W. J. Keady, and D. J. Kilpatrick Effects of breed and production system on lameness parameters in dairy cattle J Dairy Sci, May 1, 2009; 92(5): 2174 - 2182. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
O. M. Onyiro, L. J. Andrews, and S. Brotherstone Genetic Parameters for Digital Dermatitis and Correlations with Locomotion, Production, Fertility Traits, and Longevity in Holstein-Friesian Dairy Cows J Dairy Sci, October 1, 2008; 91(10): 4037 - 4046. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |