|
|
||||||||
Department of Animal Science, University of Minnesota, St. Paul 55108
1 Corresponding author: hein0106{at}umn.edu
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Key Words: calving difficulty crossbreeding heterosis stillbirth
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A survey of dairy producers conducted by Weigel and Barlass (2003) indicated that some respondents tried to reduce calving difficulty by mating their Holstein heifers to bulls of another breed. Producer scores for calving difficulty and stillbirth in the survey were best for crosses of Holstein and Jersey. Numerous studies have documented the impact of crossbreeding on calving difficulty and stillbirths, but they have been mostly limited to crossbreds of Holstein, Brown Swiss, Jersey, Ayrshire, and Guernsey (Donald, 1963; Hollon and Branton, 1975; Vesely et al., 1986; Touchberry, 1992).
From 1948 to 1962, stillbirths from 2,049 calvings in Great Britain were recorded by Donald (1963), and purebred calves of Holstein, Ayrshire, and Jersey breeds were compared with crossbred calves of each of the 3 breeds. At first calving, pure Holstein dams had 19.1% stillborn calves vs. 4.7% for Ayrshire and 11.0% for Jerseys when bred to Holstein, Ayrshire, or Jersey bulls, respectively. Crossbred calves out of purebred dams at first calving had significantly lower stillbirth rates (6.4%) than purebred calves (14.7%).
In a study by Hollon and Branton (1975), Brown Swiss-sired crosses (16.0%) had the highest calving difficulty rates when compared with pure Holsteins (11.9%) and Holstein-sired crosses (6.0%). Furthermore, pure Holsteins (12.8%) had the highest incidence of stillbirths at first calving when compared with crossbred cows sired by either Holstein (6.9%) or Brown Swiss (6.7%) bulls. Touchberry (1992) reported results of a long-term crossbreeding trial with Guernseys and Holsteins and documented significantly fewer crossbred than purebred calves dead within 24 h after birth. Of 947 Guernsey and Holstein purebred births, 9.0% had stillborn calves compared with 6.2% of 1,068 crossbred births.
Vesely et al. (1986) reported pure Holstein cows had significantly higher stillbirth rates than pure Ayrshire, Ayrshire/Holstein, and Holstein/Ayrshire crossbred cows. Pure Holstein calves (15.1%) had higher stillbirth rates than calves from Ayrshire-sired calves of Holstein dams (10.7%) and Holstein-sired calves of Ayrshire dams (7.0%). Pure Holstein cows (14.5%) had significantly more stillborn calves than Ayrshire/Holstein crossbred cows (6.4%) at first calving.
In more recent studies, McClintock et al. (2004) reported pure Holstein cows had more calving difficulty than Jersey/Holstein crossbreds. Heins et al. (2003) reported that Jersey-sired calves were born with significantly less calving difficulty than Holstein-sired calves out of pure Holstein cows.
The objectives of this study were to determine the calving difficulty and stillbirth rates 1) in pure Holstein females bred to Holstein, Brown Swiss, Normande, Montbeliarde, or Scandinavian Red (SR) bulls; and 2) in pure Holstein cows vs. crossbred cows of Holstein with Normande, Montbeliarde, and SR.
| MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
All 7 dairies were enrolled in standard milk recording. They used AI for the majority of matings; however, some natural-service Holstein and Brown Swiss bulls were used for cows that were problem breeders. Sires for AI were selected amongst highest-ranking bulls with the Net Merit index for Holsteins and similar indices for the other breeds. Herd sizes range from approximately 500 to 1,500 cows. Production of cows in these dairies is provided in Heins et al. (2006).
Data
Calving difficulty and stillbirths were recorded for calvings from June 2001 to August 2004 on 7 large commercial dairies in central California. Calving difficulty was measured on a 1 to 5 scale, with 1 = quick, easy birth with no assistance; 2 = over 2 h in labor, but no assistance; 3 = minimum assistance, but no calving difficulty; 4 = used obstetrical chains; and 5 = extremely difficult birth that required a mechanical puller. For analysis, scores of 1 to 3 were combined and represented no calving difficulty, whereas scores of 4 and 5 were combined and represented calving difficulty. Stillbirths were recorded in a binary manner as alive (1) or dead (0). A calf was considered stillborn if it died within 24 h of birth. Twin calves and calves resulting from abortions were omitted from the data. Birth weights of calves were not recorded by dairy producers and were not available.
Unadjusted means for first-calf heifers were 10.8% for calving difficulty and 10.9% for stillbirths. For multiparous cows, unadjusted means were 5.0% for calving difficulty and 5.2% for stillbirths.
Breed of Sire
Pure Holstein dams were bred to Holstein, Brown Swiss, Normande, Montbeliarde, and SR bulls and resulting calvings were used for the analysis of breed of sire. Pure Holstein dams were separated into first-calf cows and second-calf to fifth-calf cows. Normande bulls were not included in the analysis of first calving because only 24 calvings were recorded. Data for the analysis of breed of sire were collected for calvings for the entire period from June 2001 to August 2004.
Herd-year-seasons were based on 4-mo seasons of calving and derived from climatic conditions in California. June, July, August, and September are especially hot months; October, November, December, and January are rainy months; and February, March, April, and May are cool and dry months. With data spanning June 2001 to August 2004, each herd had the potential of contributing 7 year-seasons of calving for first calving and 10 year-seasons for second to fifth calving.
Each herd-year-season was required to have calvings with more than a single breed of sire. Following this edit, 45 herd-year-seasons for first calving and 55 herd-year-seasons for second to fifth calving remained. Furthermore, 1,593 first-calf and 4,041 second-calf to fifth-calf pure Holstein dams remained in the data file. The 4,041 multiparous Holsteins were composed of 1,619 second-, 1,279 third-, 742 fourth-, and 401 fifth-calving cows.
Dependent variables in the model for statistical analysis were calving difficulty and stillbirths. Independent variables for first calving were the fixed effects of herd-year-season, sex of calf, and breed of sire. For the analysis of second to fifth calving, lactation number was added as a fixed effect and cow was added as a random variable in the model. For first calving, the GLM procedure of SAS (SAS Institute, 2004) was used to obtain solutions. For second to fifth calving, the mixed model procedure of SAS (SAS Institute, 2004) was used to obtain solutions. Logistic regression (SAS Institute, 2004) was used to determine statistical significance because both calving difficulty and stillbirths were binary traits. Significance of differences between fixed effects are reported using contrasts from the logistic regression analysis.
Breed of Dam
For breed of dam, pure Holstein dams and crossbred dams of Holstein with Normande, Montbeliarde and SR were bred to Brown Swiss, Montbeliarde, and SR bulls. Breeds of sire were limited to these 3 breeds because number of births by sires of other breeds were small and were not well distributed across breed groups of dams. Therefore, all births analyzed for effect of breed of dam were for crossbred calves. Data for the analysis of breed of dam were collected for calvings from June 2002 to August 2004 and included only first and second calvings.
Herd-year-season of calving was based on the same 4-mo climatic conditions used for breed of sire, and herd-year-seasons were required to have calvings with more than a single breed group of dam. Following this edit, 51 herd-year-seasons for first calving and 26 herd-year-seasons for second calving remained for the breed of dam analysis. Also, 1,572 first calvings of heifers remained and included 676 pure Holstein dams, as well as 262 Normande/Holstein, 370 Montbeliarde/Holstein, and 264 SR/Holstein crossbred dams (Table 1
). For second calving, 307 pure Holstein dams were compared with 190 Normande/Holstein, 75 Montbeliarde/Holstein, and 69 SR/Holstein crossbred dams (Table 1
). The distribution of first-calf heifers by herd and breed group is in Table 2
. The 7 herds were variable in number of cows and in extent of use of crossbreeding.
|
|
| RESULTS AND DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Sex of calf explained significant variation (P < 0.01) for calving difficulty and stillbirths of first-calf Holstein dams as well as second-calf to fifth-calf Holstein dams. Across breeds of sire for first-calf pure Holstein cows, least squares means for calving difficulty were 15.9% for bull calves and 7.0% for heifer calves, and least squares means for stillbirth rates were 18.6% for bull calves and 5.0% for heifer calves. Cows calving for the second to fifth time had less calving difficulty and fewer stillbirths than first-calf heifers, but bull calves again were more of a problem (P < 0.01) than heifer calves for calving difficulty (7.5 vs. 4.3%) and stillbirths (8.5 vs. 5.6%).
McClintock et al. (2004) and Meyer et al. (2001a) reported that bull calves were born with more calving difficulty and higher stillbirth rates for first-calf heifers and multiparous cows; however, across all generations of a crossbreeding study, Touchberry (1992) reported more heifer calves were stillborn than bull calves. Adamec et al. (2006) and Vesely et al. (1986) reported a reduction in calving difficulty and stillbirths from bull calves in multiparous dams compared with first-calf heifers; however, the differences were not as large as this study. Larger bull calves than heifer calves and smaller pelvic dimensions in first-calf heifers compared with multiparous cows are likely factors contributing to an increase in calving difficulty and stillbirths, as suggested by Steinbock et al. (2003) and Meijering (1984).
Number of observations and least squares means for calving difficulty and stillbirths by breed of sire for first-calf and second- to fifth-calf pure Holstein dams are in Table 3
. Also, significance levels from paired contrasts from the logistic regression statistical test for effect of breed of sire on calving difficulty and stillbirths are in Table 3
. Calves sired by Holstein bulls had significantly more (P < 0.01) calving difficulty (16.4 vs. 5.5%) and stillbirths (15.1 vs. 7.7%) than calves sired by SR bulls from first-calf Holstein heifers. Holstein sires also had significantly more (P < 0.01) calving difficulty (16.4 vs. 12.5%) than Brown Swiss sires. Montbeliarde sires did not differ significantly from Holstein sires for calving difficulty or stillbirths of first-calf Holstein dams. These results are similar to Cole et al. (2005), who indicated that Brown Swiss-sired calves had slightly less calving difficulty than Holstein-sired calves. Also, McClintock et al. (2004) documented that Holstein-sired calves from Holstein dams had more calving difficulty than Jersey-sired calves from Holstein dams. Furthermore, Vesely et al. (1986) indicated than pure Holstein calves had higher stillbirth rates than crossbred calves. When surveyed, dairy producers stated that mating pure Holstein cows to Jersey or Brown Swiss sires reduced calving difficulty and stillbirths (Weigel and Barlass, 2003).
|
For the breed of sire analysis, all dams were pure Holsteins; therefore, calves sired by Holstein bulls were purebreds, whereas calves sired by bulls from other breeds were crossbreds. Crossbred calves should have more vitality from heterosis, which could result in less calving difficulty and fewer stillbirths. On the other hand, inbreeding could result in higher stillbirth rates for pure Holstein calves, due to undisclosed genetic recessives in the breed as suggested by Adamec et al. (2006). For example, complex vertebral malformation is a genetic recessive that results in fetal death (Hansen et al., 2004).
Effect of Breed of Dam
For breed group of dam, herd-year-season of first calving was significant (P < 0.05) for calving difficulty, but not significant for stillbirths. Effects of breed groups of dam, breed of sire, and sex of calf were significant (P < 0.01) for both calving difficulty and stillbirths at first calving of cows. Across breed groups of dam, calving difficulty and stillbirth rates were significantly (P < 0.01) higher in bull calves than heifer calves for first-calf heifers. Calving difficulty rates were 14.7% for bull calves and 5.3% for heifer calves, and stillbirth rates were 15.4% for bull calves and 2.2% for heifer calves. Once again, these results for sex of calf are similar to those of Adamec et al. (2006), McClintock et al. (2004), Meyer et al. (2001a), and Touchberry (1992). For second-calf dams, only breed of sire was significant (P < 0.05) for stillbirths. No other effects were significant for stillbirths, and no effects were significant for calving difficulty for second-calf dams.
Number of observations and least squares means for breed groups of dam for calving difficulty and stillbirths for 1,572 first-calf heifers and 641 second-calf cows are in Table 4
. Furthermore, paired contrasts from the logistic regression significance test for breed groups of dam for first-calf heifers and second-calf cows are in Table 4
. Pure Holsteins (17.7%) had significantly (P < 0.01) more calving difficulty than Montbeliarde/Holstein (7.2%) and SR/Holstein (3.7%) crossbreds at first calving, and pure Holsteins had significantly (P < 0.05) more calving difficulty than Normande/Holstein crossbreds (11.6%). Stillbirth rates tended to follow calving difficulty rates for breed groups of dam at first calving, and pure Holstein heifers (14.0%) had significantly (P < 0.01) higher stillbirth rates than Montbeliarde/Holstein (6.2%) and SR/Holstein (5.1%) crossbred heifers. Pure Holstein heifers also tended to have higher stillbirth rates than Normande/Holstein crossbred heifers (9.9%). The results for stillbirths agree with the results of Hollon and Branton (1975) and Vesely et al. (1986), who reported pure Holstein cows at first calving had higher stillbirth rates than crossbred cows. McClintock et al. (2004) reported pure Holstein cows had more calving difficulty than Jersey/Holstein crossbred cows.
|
Dematawewa and Berger (1997) indicated calving difficulty in Holsteins is associated with reduced milk production, longer days open, and lower survival. Dairy producers report less calving difficulty and fewer stillbirths when Holstein cows are crossed with Jersey and Brown Swiss bulls (Weigel and Barlass, 2003). Crossbreeding might be effective in reducing calving difficulty and stillbirths, thereby reducing costs associated with difficult births, including lower milk production and longer days open.
For cows that calved a second time, calving difficulty and stillbirth rates were lower than those for first-calf heifers. These results agree with Meyer et al. (2001b) and indicate that most calving difficulty and stillbirths occur for first-calf heifers. Breed groups of dam were not significantly different from one another for calving difficulty or stillbirths.
| CONCLUSIONS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
First-calf Normande/Holstein, Montbeliarde/Holstein, and SR/Holstein crossbred heifers had significantly less calving difficulty than first-calf pure Holsteins. Also, Montbeliarde/Holstein and SR/Holstein crossbred heifers had significantly fewer stillbirths than first-calf pure Holsteins.
The results of this study suggest that dairy producers can lessen calving difficulty and reduce stillbirths by crossing Holstein cows with bulls of other dairy breeds, and the resulting crossbred females will also tend to have lessened calving difficulty and reduced stillbirths at first calving. Additional research should aid in determining if the economics of dairy production justify the use of crossbreeding as a tool to reduce calving difficulty and stillbirths.
| ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Received for publication October 28, 2005. Accepted for publication February 8, 2006.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
B. J. Heins, L. B. Hansen, A. J. Seykora, A. R. Hazel, D. G. Johnson, and J. G. Linn Crossbreds of Jersey x Holstein Compared with Pure Holsteins for Body Weight, Body Condition Score, Dry Matter Intake, and Feed Efficiency During the First One Hundred Fifty Days of First Lactation J Dairy Sci, September 1, 2008; 91(9): 3716 - 3722. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
B. J. Heins, L. B. Hansen, A. J. Seykora, D. G. Johnson, J. G. Linn, J. E. Romano, and A. R. Hazel Crossbreds of Jersey x Holstein Compared with Pure Holsteins for Production, Fertility, and Body and Udder Measurements During First Lactation J Dairy Sci, March 1, 2008; 91(3): 1270 - 1278. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
B. Heringstad, Y. M. Chang, M. Svendsen, and D. Gianola Genetic Analysis of Calving Difficulty and Stillbirth in Norwegian Red Cows J Dairy Sci, July 1, 2007; 90(7): 3500 - 3507. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
C. D. Dechow, G. W. Rogers, J. B. Cooper, M. I. Phelps, and A. L. Mosholder Milk, Fat, Protein, Somatic Cell Score, and Days Open Among Holstein, Brown Swiss, and Their Crosses J Dairy Sci, July 1, 2007; 90(7): 3542 - 3549. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
B. J. Heins, L. B. Hansen, and A. J. Seykora Fertility and Survival of Pure Holsteins Versus Crossbreds of Holstein with Normande, Montbeliarde, and Scandinavian Red J Dairy Sci, December 1, 2006; 89(12): 4944 - 4951. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |