|
|
||||||||
1 Filière Blanche, 12 Quai Duguay Trouin, 35000 Rennes, France
2 Véto 70, 35 Grande Rue, 70160 Faverney, France
3 Boehringer Ingelheim, B.P. 292, 51060 Reims, France
4 Harlan Bioservice for Science GmbH, 29664 Walsrode, Germany
5 Boehringer Ingelheim Animal Health GmbH, 55216 Ingelheim am Rhein, Germany
Corresponding author: Laurent Goby; e-mail: gobyl{at}rei.boehringer-ingelheim.com.
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Key Words: antibiotic treatment administration route comparative efficacy mastitis
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
However, the practical recommendations for the route of treatment are heterogeneous. In northern Europe, the parenteral route is widely used to treat all types of mastitis, whereas, in other countries, it depends more on how the disease is presented, e.g., the parenteral route is often reserved for the treatment of severe clinical mastitis or chronic infections caused by Staphylococcus aureus with bacteria located in the udder parenchyma.
Clinical studies comparing the efficacy of treatments given by either intramammary or parenteral routes are rare. At drying off, for example, the systemic treatment of subclinical infections with norfloxacin resulted in a higher bacteriological cure rate than that achieved by the intramammary administration of cephapirin (Soback et al., 1990). In cases of clinical mastitis during lactation caused by an experimental infection with Streptococcus uberis, no significant difference in bacteriological cure was reported between a regimen of systemic treatment with a combination of procaine penicillin and dihydrostreptomycin (3 daily injections of 5 g of penicillin and 6.25 g of dihydrostreptomycin) and an "aggressive" intramammary treatment regimen consisting of 6 administrations of a proprietary presentation containing penethamate, dihydrostreptomycin, and framycetin (Hillerton and Kliem, 2002). In a New Zealand field trial, where Strep. uberis was the predominant causative pathogen, systemic treatment with penethamate (10 g followed 24 h later by 5 g) resulted in an overall bacteriological cure rate of clinical mastitis of 76.4%; intramammary administration of a combination of 1 g of procaine penicillin and 0.5 g of dihydrostreptomycin at 3 consecutive milkings achieved a cure rate of 84.9% (McDougall, 1998). This difference was explained by a significantly better efficacy of the intramammary treatment against the clinical infections caused by coagulase-negative staphylococci. On the other hand, the systemic treatment with penethamate allowed collateral cure of subclinical infections present in adjacent quarters.
The aim of this field study was to compare the efficacy of 2 antibiotic treatments differing in their active compounds (penethamate or an ampicillin/cloxacillin combination), and their route of administration (parenteral vs. local). Efficacy was assessed using bacteriological cure, clinical recovery, and milk SCC.
| MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Selection of Animals
To be included in the study, cows had to meet all of the following inclusion criteria: 1) clinical mastitis in only one quarter simultaneously exhibiting udder edema and macroscopically abnormal milk without or with systemic signs; 2) parity <4 lactations; 3) stage of lactation <6 mo; 4) no concurrent disease; 5) no teat lesions; 6) no clinical mastitis or anti-infectious or anti-inflammatory treatments within the last 14 d; and 7) no previous inclusion in the study.
To control the most significant confounding parameter, the study was stratified by parity by including the same number of cows (104) in their first, second, and third lactation.
After entry into the study, cows were withdrawn if there was deviation from the planned treatment regimens or they received additional treatment during the study period due to a concurrent disease arising or due to mastitis arising in another quarter in addition to that originally affected.
Treatment
Animals meeting the inclusion criteria were randomly allocated to a treatment, using a closed envelope method.
The systemic treatment consisted of daily intramuscular injections of penethamate hydriodide (Mamyzin/ Stop M, Boehringer Ingelheim GmbH, Ingelheim, Germany) for 3 consecutive days at a dose of 15 mg/kg of BW on d 1, followed by 7.5 mg/kg on d 2 and 3 (1 µg of penethamate hydriodide provides 1 IU of penicillin G). The injections were made in the neck region, alternating the side of administration on each day of treatment.
The intramammary treatment consisted of the infusion (through the teat canal of the clinically affected quarter after disinfection of the teat end) of a proprietary combination containing 200 mg of cloxacillin and 75 mg of ampicillin (Ampiclox, Pfizer, Paris, France) once a day for 3 d, according to its licensed use in France.
Clinical Examinations
Cows included in the study underwent clinical examination at d 1, 3, 8, 17, and 22. The veterinarian investigator assessed general condition, rectal temperature, heart rate, udder edema, and appearance of milk; the farmer recorded decreases in feed intake and milk yield.
Rectal temperature and heart rate were measured directly, whereas other clinical parameters were scored on a numerical scale ranging from normal to slightly, moderately, or severely impaired.
Milk Sampling
Milk samples were aseptically collected (IDF, 1981) from the affected quarters on d 1 (immediately before treatment), 17, and 22 for bacteriological investigations. Samples were frozen at 20°C within 2 h of collection.
Further milk samples were collected from each quarter on d 1, 8, 17, and 22 into flasks containing potassium dichromate at a final concentration of approximately 0.1% for SCC determination.
Laboratory Procedures
The bacteriological investigations were carried out by the Public Veterinary Laboratory at Vesoul (France).
Bacteriological culture and identification were performed according to the National Mastitis Council standard (Harmon et al., 1990). A quarter milk sample was considered contaminated when 3 or more colony types of bacteria could be isolated. Identification of specific bacterial species was performed for coagulase-positive staphylococci, CNS, streptococci, enterococci, corynebacteria, arcanobacteria, other gram-positive bacteria, enterobacteriae, and other gram-negative bacilli. Different species of yeasts were not characterized.
Quarter milk SCC were determined by the fluoro-optoelectronic method using a Fossomatic 360 device (Foss Electric, Hillerød, Denmark) according to the International Dairy Federation standard (1995). Measurement was usually carried out on the day of collection within 2 h. If this was not possible, the samples were stored at 4°C and tested within 2 d.
Definitions of Cure
Bacteriological cure was considered to have been achieved if the samples taken from the affected quarter on d 17 and 22 were free of the bacterial species isolated in the pretreatment sample. All cows with a missing or contaminated sample taken on d 1, 17, or 22, and those negative for bacterial isolation on d 1 were excluded from the analysis.
A bacteriological cure rate was calculated excluding cows which had to be retreated for mastitis in the same quarter as originally affected or in which the therapy of mastitis had to be changed. In addition, a so-called actual bacteriological cure rate was calculated, considering those cases as treatment failure.
Clinical cure was defined as the disappearance of clinical signs of disease which were observed on d 1 before treatment, in other words, by the return to normal feed intake, rectal temperature <39.0°C, good general condition, absence of udder edema, normal milk appearance, and normal milk yield.
Statistical Analysis
The difference in bacteriological cure between treatments were analyzed using the Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel test controlling for lactation number. The percentage of animals achieving clinical cure was compared following the same procedure. The qualitative variables, feed intake, general condition, udder edema, appearance of milk, and milk yield were analyzed at each observation day after initiation of therapy using the Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel test controlling for lactation number and pretreatment value. The continuous quantitative variables, rectal temperature and heart rate, were subjected to ANOVA with lactation number as controlled factor and pretreatment value as covariate.
Differences in the evolution of SCC on d 8, 17, and 21 after initiation of therapy were analyzed by repeated measures ANOVA with factors treatment and lactation number and with baseline values on d 1 as covariate using logarithmically transformed values on a cow basis. Comparison between treatments was performed considering the clinically affected quarter, the clinically unaffected quarters, and all quarters of each cow, successively. Those analyses were performed considering the log transformed SCC value of individual quarters.
The evolution of the SCC was analyzed considering the inflammatory status of the quarters in relation to the threshold of 250,000 cells/mL (Salionemi, 1995; Djabri et al., 2002). The quarters with SCC above the threshold of 250,000 cells/mL before treatment were classified according to their SCC returning or not to below this threshold on d 8, 17, and 22 following treatment. The significance of the differences between the 2 treatments was assessed using the Fishers exact test.
The statistical analyses were carried out using SAS software, release 6.11 (SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC).
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
Staphylococcus aureus, Strep. uberis, Escherichia coli, and CNS were the predominant causative pathogens (Table 2
). The cure rates of infections with Staph. aureus were identical (24%) in the 2 treatment groups. The cure rates of the infections due to Strep. uberis, CNS, and the overall gram-positive species were higher in cows treated systemically with penethamate, although differences were not statistically significant.
|
|
Mean values of rectal temperature were below 39.0°C in both groups over the whole trial. The mean values of heart rate remained within a physiological range, with values under 90 beats/min in both groups during the study.
Somatic Cell Counts
Clinically affected quarters.
The geometric mean values of milk SCC in clinically affected quarters were initially over 4,000,000 cells/mL in both groups on d 1 and decreased sharply in both groups after treatment. The repeated measures ANOVA on d 8, 17, and 22 showed no significant difference in the evolution of SCC between the treatments (Table 4
).
|
0.05) and approached significance on d 22 (P = 0.066).
|
All quarters.
The geometric mean values of milk SCC of all 4 quarters did not differ significantly between the treatment groups throughout the study period (Table 4
).
The proportion of quarters (clinically affected or not) with SCC returning below the threshold of 250,000 cells/mL after treatment was higher in the systemic treatment group compared with the intramammary treatment group, with values of 40 vs. 28% on d 17 and 43 vs. 30% on d 22, respectively (Table 5
). These differences were highly significant (P
0.01).
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In the cases where Staph. aureus was isolated, the parenteral treatment with penethamate achieved the same bacteriological cure rate as the local treatment with the ampicillin/cloxacillin combination, despite the inactivity of benzylpenicillin against the ß-lactamase-producing strains (averaging 50% of the isolates in France; Guérin-Faublée and Brun, 1999). It should be noted that in this study, the majority of isolated Staph. aureus was sensitive to ampicillin or cloxacillin in the intramammary treatment group, whereas in the penethamate group, the in vitro sensitivity of most of the Staph. aureus was intermediate. As the cure rate was similar after both treatments, this suggests a better efficacy of the penethamate treatment against the sensitive ß-lactamase-negative strains, possibly in relation with the lower MIC of benzylpenicillin compared with cloxacillin (Guérin-Faublée and Brun, 1999); it may also be due to improved diffusion of the active ingredient in the udder tissue after administration by the parenteral route (Ziv and Storper, 1985). Therefore, the penethamate treatment (which here achieved a bacteriological cure rate of 24% in Staph. aureus clinical mastitis cases) could be more specifically indicated in herds where the predominant strain is negative to the nitrocefine test or other tests indicating the secretion of ß-lactamase (Jarlov and Rosdahl, 1986).
In clinical cases caused by Strep. uberis, the bacteriological cure rate achieved by both treatments was above 70%. This result is consistent with previous studies that compared the respective efficacy of a systemic administration of penethamate and an intramammary penethamate/dihydrostreptomycin/framycetin preparation (Hillerton and Kliem, 2002), or to an intramammary penicillin/dihydrostreptomycin combination (McDougall, 1998).
Enterobacteria species were identified in about 25% of the cases suitable for analysis. This low proportion probably underestimates the real incidence of these species in clinical mastitis. Absence of bacterial isolation in milk when clinical signs are present is often associated with infections due to these species (Zorah et al., 1993), especially if the milk samples have been frozen (Schukken et al., 1989). The bacteriological cure rate of 62% in the group receiving the penethamate treatment may be interpreted as spontaneous cures, which are reportedly frequent in this kind of infection (Jones, 1990).
With more than 80% of cows clinically cured on the eighth day after the start of therapy, regression of the clinical signs appeared to be satisfactory and similar for both treatments.
The study showed a tendency toward more pronounced reduction in milk SCC following systemic treatment with penethamate. The difference in the proportion of quarters returning below the threshold of 250,000 cells/mL after treatment reached statistical significance on d 17 for the clinically affected quarters, on d 22 for the clinically unaffected quarters, and on d 17 and 22 for all quarters regardless of whether they were clinically affected before treatment. Milk SCC accurately reflects the mammary health status of quarters and is a reliable indicator of udder inflammation caused by IMI (Dohoo et al., 1984; Harmon, 1994; Barkema et al., 1999). Therefore, the decreased SCC observed after parenteral administration of penethamate in the quarters not affected by clinical mastitis may indicate a beneficial collateral effect of this treatment on quarters potentially having subclinical mastitis.
Furthermore, weak base antibiotics (such as penethamate hydriodide) concentrate in the milk following systemic treatment, more so in subclinical than in clinical mastitis, because the inflammation is mild and the milk pH is low (Ziv, 1980b). Ziv and Storper (1985) reported a 62.7% bacteriological cure rate in subclinical infections due to penicillin-sensitive Staph. aureus after only 2 daily injections of 5 g of penethamate. The recommended treatment regimen of penethamate hydriodide in France (3 daily administrations of 10 g, 5 g, and 5 g), achieved concentrations in milk above the minimum inhibitory concentration values of most of the sensitive pathogens over the whole treatment period (Friton et al., 2003). St. Rose et al. (2003) achieved a bacteriological cure rate of 58.6% against subclinical Strep. uberis and Streptococcus dysgalactiae infections vs. 0% in an untreated control group following the same regimen.
In The Netherlands, Barkema et al. (1997) found that the cows suffering from subclinical mastitis were affected in 2 quarters on average. In the current trial, for each quarter with clinical mastitis at the start of antibiotic treatment, there was an average of 1.2 quarters suspected of being affected by subclinical mastitis on the basis of SCC above the threshold of 250,000 cells/ mL (Salionemi, 1995; Djabri et al., 2002).
Consequently, when choosing an antibiotic compound and its route of administration for treatment of clinical mastitis, particular attention should be paid (besides the identification of the causative pathogen and its possible localization in the udder) to the number of quarters potentially affected by subclinical mastitis. In practice, it can be carried out on the basis of milk SCC or other means to detect quarter inflammation, such as electric conductivity or California Mastitis Test. Further studies are required to assess the respective economic interest of either intramammary or systemic antibiotic treatments according to the type of infection and the number of quarters per cow subject to clinical or subclinical infection.
| CONCLUSIONS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Received for publication March 19, 2004. Accepted for publication September 3, 2004.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
O. Salat, F. Serieys, B. Poutrel, L. Durel, and L. Goby Systemic Treatment of Subclinical Mastitis in Lactating Cows with Penethamate Hydriodide J Dairy Sci, February 1, 2008; 91(2): 632 - 640. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. McDougall, K. E. Agnew, R. Cursons, X. X. Hou, and C. R. W. Compton Parenteral Treatment of Clinical Mastitis with Tylosin Base or Penethamate Hydriodide in Dairy Cattle J Dairy Sci, February 1, 2007; 90(2): 779 - 789. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
H. W. Barkema, Y. H. Schukken, and R. N. Zadoks Invited Review: The role of cow, pathogen, and treatment regimen in the therapeutic success of bovine Staphylococcus aureus mastitis. J Dairy Sci, June 1, 2006; 89(6): 1877 - 1895. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. Soback Reply to: "Letter to the Editor: Concerning an Article Comparing the Efficacy of Local and Systemic Treatment of Clinical Mastitis" J Dairy Sci, December 1, 2005; 88(12): 4135 - 4135. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. Pyorala Letter to the Editor: Concerning an Article Comparing the Efficacy of Local and Systemic Treatment of Clinical Mastitis J Dairy Sci, May 1, 2005; 88(5): 1617 - 1617. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |