|
|
||||||||

* MATFORSK Norwegian Food Research Institute, 1430 Ås, Norway
TINE Norwegian Dairies BA, 4358 Kleppe, Norway
Corresponding author:
J. P. Wold; e-mail:
jens.petter.wold{at}matforsk.no.
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A significant reduction in fluorescence intensity at approximately 525 nm, and a corresponding increase in the region 415 to 490 nm as a result of illumination was observed on all the products. The effect was ascribed to photodegradation of riboflavin. Variation in two smaller peaks at approximately 620 nm and 630 nm was an interaction effect between exposure to light and air. A pronounced interaction effect between light and air produced intense blue fluorescence and off-flavors on Swiss-like Jarlsberg cheese. High correlations (0.83 to 0.93) between fluorescence spectra and sensory measured off-flavors were obtained for cream cheese. Results indicate that solid-sample fluorescence can be used as a nondestructive and rapid tool to measure the degree of light-induced degradation of riboflavin as well as sensory properties connected to storage of dairy products. Images of fluorescence can be used to visualize the intensity and propagation of this process. The simplicity and rapidity of the method offer rich opportunities for efficient evaluation of factors affecting light-induced oxidation in dairy products, such as packaging materials, light sources, exposure time, and temperature.
Key Words: light-induced oxidation dairy product fluorescence image analysis
Abbreviation key: ESR = electronic spin resonance, PC = principal component, PCA = PC analysis, PLSR = partial least squares regression, RMSECV = root mean square error of cross validation
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Fluorescence is an intuitive choice for at least three reasons. First, the oxidation of unsaturated lipids in foods leads to the formation of hydroperoxides and secondary off-flavor compounds including aldehydes and ketones. These products can further react with macromolecules in the food matrix and create fluorescent compounds (Kikugawa and Beppu, 1987). These fluorescent compounds have successfully been utilized to detect lipid oxidation in foods by both solution and solid-sample fluorescence spectroscopy (Hasegawa, 1992; Aubourg, 1999; Wold and Mielnik, 2000). Liang (1999) showed that the correlation between storage time for milk powders and fluorescence (R = 0.95) was significantly higher than that between storage time and peroxide value or concentration of thiobarbituric reactive substances. Second, riboflavin is highly fluorescent, as are the breakdown products from photodegradation, lumiflavin, and lumichrome (Fox and Thayer, 1998). Since this process is believed to play a major role in the induction of free radicals and lipid oxidation, fluorescence can be expected to constitute an important marker of early lipid oxidation in dairy products. Third, solid-sample fluorescence spectroscopy is inexpensive, rapid, and nondestructive and lends itself to imaging techniques, such as the imaging of biochemical processes, e.g., lipid oxidation as proposed by Wold and Kvaal (2000).
Preliminary studies carried out at our laboratory showed pronounced changes in fluorescence from various dairy products after storage under different conditions of exposure to light and air. The purpose of this paper is to demonstrate the potential of solid sample fluorescence spectroscopy in nondestructive assessment of light-induced oxidation in different dairy products such as Swiss cheese, cream cheese, and sour cream. Analytical and quantitative spectral properties of fluorescence were elucidated by use of principal component analysis (PCA) with designed experiments involving different levels of air and light exposure. The relation between fluorescence and sensory assessed properties was analyzed by partial least squares regression (PLSR). We also illustrated how imaging of fluorescence can be used to visualize the intensity and spatial propagation of light-induced oxidation in the dairy products. Examples will be shown and possible applications discussed.
| MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Experimental Design
Our first goal was to detect any changes in fluorescence caused by exposure to light and air. We did this by conducting exploratory designs using goat cream cheese, sour cream, and Jarlsberg cheese. Our second goal was to establish relationship between fluorescence and sensory attributes related to storage. This was achieved by conducting measurements on illuminated cream cheese.
Effects of light and air.
To detect changes in fluorescence, we set up the following storage experiment:
All products were stored under four different conditions at 4°C: Light with exposure to air, light with no exposure to air, dark with exposure to air, and dark without exposure to air.
For each product we used two storage times and triplicate samples at each design point. This resulted in a total of 21 samples for each product (4 x 3 x 2 – 3). Samples stored in the dark without air access would have been identical for the two storage times, so we used only one set, which explains the "–3" above. All samples of each specific product were measured on the same day, meaning that they were introduced in the experiment at different times.
Illumination.
A standard fluorescent tube (Osram L58W/21.840 Lumilux plus) was used for illuminating the samples during storage. It emits light mainly in the visible region, with some in the UV, and is commonly used for displays in grocery stores. The products were positioned 10 cm from the tube (which mimics conditions in grocery stores). Samples stored in the dark were placed in light-proof cases.
Goat cream cheese.
Containers (125 g) of goat cream cheese were stored for 3 and 7 d. Commercial triangular (sides
10 cm) containers (height
2 cm) of white plastic were used (material with high oxygen barrier (PP/EVOH/PP) from Forscheim, Germany). The boxes had a plastic white wafer seal (high barrier laminate (PETP/PE/EVOH/PE) from Ronsberg, Ronsberg, Germany) and a white plastic cover (PP/EVOH/PP), Forscheim, Germany). To allow air access, we removed the sealing, leaving those boxes with only the plastic cover. The boxes were illuminated from above, that is, the triangular surface under the cover was exposed to both air and light.
Sour cream.
The sour cream cups were stored for 2 and 4 d. Commercial 3-dl circular cups of white polystyrene (PLM, Malmö, Sweden) were used. The cups had a thin aluminum wafer seal and a circular polystyrene cover on top. To allow air access, we removed the aluminum wafer sealing from the top, leaving those cups with only polystyrene covers. Cups were illuminated from the side and above of a vertical standing fluorescent tube. That is, the horizontal top of the sample was exposed to both air and light, whereas the vertical side of the cup was exposed only to light.
Jarlsberg cheese.
The cheese was stored for 3 and 7 d in commercial flow packages of transparent laminate plastic film (OPA 12/PE50 from Wipak, Nastola, Finland). The transparent side (without any labels or emblems) of the packages was turned against the light. Air access was achieved by puncturing the packages with a needle. That is, air had access to all sides, whereas only one side of the cheese was illuminated.
Riboflavin.
As an additional control, a solution of 10 mg of riboflavin (Sigma Chemical Co., St. Louis, MO) in 800 ml of water was made. It was divided in two 400-ml portions, where one was stored in the dark, while the other was stored in the light under the same conditions as the dairy products.
Sensory assessment of illuminated cream cheese.
Two whole loaves of cream cheese were illuminated for 4 and 7 d using the same fluorescent tubes as described above. They were vacuum packed in commercial transparent plastic film (Lakk/Cellofan/EVA from Danapak, Odense, Denmark). Sides without labels or emblems were turned toward the light. There was no air access (except for that allowed by the permeability of the packing material).
After storage, the loaves were divided into subsamples according to Figure 1
. Six slices of thickness 2.5 mm were cut from the top of the loaf and down from the side that had been illuminated. Each slice was divided into six subsamples for sensory evaluation with the seventh subsample used for spectroscopic measurements. Every sensory judge tasted a total of 12 subsamples, six from each cheese. Fluorescence was measured on the corresponding subsamples. We had observed in advance that there were fluorescent gradients in the different products. The reason for evaluating different layers in the cheese was to determine whether the sensory panel was also able to detect and describe these fluorescent gradients in the cheese.
|
6 cm) was used. The samples were illuminated by 380 nm excitation light, and fluorescence emission spectra were measured in the range 400 to 640 nm. The excitation light was generated by a 300 W Xenon light source (Oriel 6258, Oriel Corporation, Stratford, CT) and a 10-nm bandwidth interference filter (Oriel 59920). The light was directed onto the samples at an angle of about 45°. The spectra were collected by an imaging spectrograph (Acton SP-150, Acton Research Corp., Acton, MA) connected to a sensitive charge coupled device (CCD-camera; Princeton TEA/CCD-512-TKBM1, Princeton Instruments Inc., Trenton, NJ). A cut-off filter at 400 nm (Melles Griot 03FCG049) was positioned in front of the spectrograph slit to suppress excitation light reflected from the sample. Exposure time was 1 s for all spectroscopic measurements. Temperature of samples was 16 to 19°C. Two spectra were collected from each sample, and the average was used for further analysis. Spectrograph and detector were controlled by the software WinSpec Ver. 1.4.3.4 (Princeton Instruments Inc.). Spectra were digitized to a resolution of 16 bit and the length reduced from 512 to 128 points by averaging four adjacent readings, resulting in one reading for approximately every second nanometer. Images were collected with the same system, slightly modified. A Nikon 102 mm photographic lens was mounted on the imaging spectrograph, the spectrograph slit was removed and the grating exchanged with a mirror. Spectral images were created by placing 40 nm bandwidth interference filters in front of the lens. Samples were illuminated by 380 nm light and images were taken at 450 and 550 nm. Exposure time for all images was 15 s.
Goat cream cheese.
Fluorescence spectra were measured on all 21 samples. The following measurements were performed on each sample: 1) plastic cover and plastic wafer were removed from the container and fluorescence was measured on the surface of the cheese while in the container (measured circular area: D
5 cm); 2) The cheese was tipped out of the container and a vertical cut was made through the middle. One of the rectangular cross sections was measured (A
2 x 5 cm); and 3) the other cross section was imaged. The purpose was to determine whether it was possible to detect an fluorescence gradient in the image.
Sour cream.
Fluorescence spectra were measured on 14 of 21 samples (two of three triplicates). The following measurements were performed: 1) plastic cover and aluminum wafer were removed from the cups and fluorescence was measured on the surface (measured circular area: D
5 cm); 2) sour cream against the vertical side of the cup exposed only to light was drawn out with a spoon, placed in cuvettes (D = 5 cm) and measured; and 3) The remaining seven samples were frozen (–25°C) and thawed 2 wk later for imaging. Each cup was cut vertically in half with a sharp knife along the side that had been exposed to light. The cross sections were then imaged.
Jarlsberg cheese.
Fluorescence spectra were measured on 14 of 21 samples (two of three triplicates). 1) A cylinder (D = 5 cm) was cut from the center of each cheese. The flat top of the cylinder was the illuminated surface of the cheese. This top surface was measured. Then, with a cheese slicer, we sectioned 1-mm thick slices off the cylinder from the top. For each slice, a new measurement was done in order to investigate possible fluorescence gradients in the samples; 2) A cross section of each of the last seven samples was imaged.
Cream cheese.
Fluorescence spectra from the 12 subsamples (six from each loaf) that had been subjected to sensory evaluation were all measured at site no. 7 (Figure 1
).
Riboflavin.
Fluorescence spectra were measured from the two riboflavin solutions.
Sensory Evaluation
The sensory evaluation was performed by a trained sensory panel with special skills for evaluating dairy products. The panel, consisting of six trained assessors, carried out a prescribed descriptive test (ISO 1985). Before the analysis, the panel was trained in the definition and intensities of the four chosen attributes using cream cheese with varying sensory properties. These attributes were oxidized odor, oxidized flavor, total odor, and total flavor. Each assessor was served each cheese sample on a cardboard plate. The judgement was performed in two rounds, one for each of the two cream cheese loaves. The serving order was randomized according to sample and assessor. Water and crackers were provided to cleanse the palate between samples. A continuous nonstructured scale was used for evaluation of sensory attributes ranging from the lowest intensity of each attribute (value 1.0) to the highest intensity (value 9.0). Each judge evaluated the samples at individual speed on a computer system for direct recording of data (CSA, Compusense, Version 4.2, Guelph, ON, Canada). The sensory scores for each layer of cheese were obtained by averaging the individual scores for the six subsamples from the same layer.
Data Analysis
PCA was applied to the spectral data from all the experiments in order to get the best possible view of the spectral structure. Scores, loadings, and explained variance were studied for the first three to four principal components (PC). Loading plots were used to interpret the spectral variation contained in each PC, while score plots were used to visualize the relation between samples in the corresponding PC. The spectra were not subjected to any kind of preprocessing before analysis.
The PLSR (Martens and Næs, 1989) was attempted for making a calibration between fluorescence and sensory assessed attributes on cream cheese. Full cross validation was used for all models. This provided a predicted value for each sample,
i, which was compared to the reference sensory value, yi. Multivariate correlation coefficient (R) and the prediction error expressed as root mean square error of cross validation (RMSECV) were used to evaluate the models. RMSECV was defined as
![]() |
where i denotes the samples from 1 to N. Data analyses were performed with the software The Unscrambler version 7.5 (Camo AS, Oslo, Norway).
Images were imported into ImagePro Plus version 4.5 (Media Cybernetics, L.P., Silver Spring, MD). Possible gradients in fluorescence intensity were detected by simply studying the gray level values of the pixels.
| RESULTS AND DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Goat Cream Cheese and Sour Cream
Figure 2a and b
show the main spectral features of the fluorescence from goat cheese and sour cream measured at the surface (measurement no. 1), respectively. There are two spectral regions that are of particular interest; the broad peak around 520 to 530 nm (designated the 525 nm peak) which is yellow/green in color, and the region 415 to 490 nm, which is violet and blue. Visually, it is apparent that samples stored in the dark demonstrated intense fluorescence around 525 nm, and correspondingly low fluorescence in the violet region. Illuminated samples, however, showed less difference between these regions, indicating a reduction of fluorescence around 525 nm and an increase in the violet area. Consequently, illuminated samples appeared more violet. It was also observed that this change was gradual and seemed to have been mostly dependent on light exposure time. It is noteworthy that the fluorescent properties for the two products are very similar, differing only by a more intense fluorescence in the 415 to 490 nm for the longest illuminated goat cheese. This might be explained by the longer storage period (7 vs. 4 d for sour cream). The loading plots shown in Figure 2c and d
confirm the spectral similarities between the two products. The spectral shapes of the three first principal components were almost identical. First component explained 96.7 and 98.1% of the spectral variation in goat cheese and sour cream, respectively. This component represents the reduction at 525 nm, and some of the increase at 415 to 490 nm. Second component (3.1 and 1.5% explained variance, respectively) expressed additional variation in the 415 to 540 nm region but was not correlated with the reduction at 525 nm. Third component (0.18 and 0.26%) had most of its variation in a narrow spectral region at approximately 630 nm. This peak corresponds to the two very small bumps in the raw spectra at 620 and 630 nm.
|
|
7 to 8 mm), suggesting that the effect of light exposure propagated a considerable distance into the cheese. The images of sour cream cross sections (Figure 5
|
|
Even without any chemical reference analyses, it is possible to suggest possible reactions leading to the changes in fluorescence. Riboflavin has a strong and broad fluorescence emission peak in the region 525 to 531 nm (Fox and Thayer, 1998). It also has a broad excitation spectrum including 380 nm, the excitation wavelength used in our study. It is known that when riboflavin is illuminated by fluorescent light, it is photochemically degraded into different forms of lumichrome and lumiflavin. These compounds are also fluorescent with emission maxima in the regions 444 to 479 nm and 516 to 522 nm, respectively (Fox and Thayer, 1998). Furthermore, lumichrome has been found to occur naturally in milk and pasta exposed to light (Parks and Allen, 1977; Woodcock et al., 1982; Toyosaki and Hayashi, 1993). Although the reported excitation and emission maxima were found by solution spectroscopy, the mechanism seems to fit our observations for cheese and sour cream. The reduction of fluorescence around 525 nm might reflect the degradation of riboflavin. Some of the increase in the region 415 to 490 nm might be caused by the formation of lumichrome. There was also a slight shift of the 525 nm peak towards 520 nm (especially for the goat cheese) which might involve the formation of lumiflavin. Fluorescence spectrophotometers might produce fluorescence spectra with slight differences because they consist of different optical components. To make a proper comparison between fluorescence from the dairy products and riboflavin, it was important to measure the riboflavin solutions with our system. Figure 6
shows spectra from the riboflavin solution stored in the dark as well as from the same solution illuminated for 3 d with the same lamp that was used on the dairy products. The solution had an emission peak at about 525 nm. The illuminated solution exhibited significantly less fluorescence around 525 nm, but an increase in the region 420 to 510 nm, probably caused by formation of lumichrome. Note that the spectra for riboflavin are very similar to the major peaks obtained for sour cream and goat cheese. This experiment supports the hypothesis that photochemical degradation of riboflavin caused the major change in fluorescence.
|
The variation in the region 410 to 560 nm, which did not correlate with the reduction of the peak at 525 nm (PC2), might be ascribed to the reaction between primary and secondary lipid oxidation products with proteins to form fluorescent compounds (Kikugawa and Beppu, 1987). Such products typically exhibit fluorescence between 400 and 500 nm. For example, Liang (1999) found that oxidized milk powder has an emission maximum at 450 nm for solid-sample fluorescence.
Lastly, the effect of the third PC was, as mentioned, probably caused by exposure to air. So far, we have not elucidated the chemical origin of the two tiny peaks at 620 and 630 nm.
Jarlsberg Cheese
Fluorescence measurements on Jarlsberg cheese revealed many of the same properties observed for goat cheese and sour cream. One significant difference was, however, a very powerful blue fluorescence emitted from the surface of cheeses that had been exposed to both light and air. These samples were also accompanied by intense off-flavors and suffered from discoloration (less yellow, more pale). Figure 7
shows spectra measured on the six uppermost cheese slices taken from a sample stored for 7 d in light with access to air. The first slice at the surface (slice 1) exhibited a strong blue fluorescence peaking at approximately 480 nm; however, at slice 2 we observed a spectrum similar to those observed on the other dairy products. Penetrating deeper into the cheese the intensity at 525 nm continued to increase until stabilizing at 5 to 6 mm depth (slice no. 5 and 6). A spectrum from a surface slice of a cheese stored in the dark is plotted for comparison. The strong blue fluorescence was observed down to a depth of about 1 mm. The images in Figure 8
illustrate these observations. The two upper images are of the same cheese sample, the topmost taken at 450 nm and the other one at 550 nm. The topmost slice showed the propagation of the blue fluorescence as a bright zone, whereas the middle image showed the reduced intensity at 525 nm as a dark region stretching about 6 mm into the cheese, in accordance with the spectral results in Figure 7
. The lower cheese was stored in the dark and showed no obvious gradients in fluorescence.
|
|
Fluorescence and Sensory Analysis of Cream Cheese
The sensory evaluation was carried out in an effort to establish a connection between fluorescence and quality properties related to storage. During the above-discussed experiments, we generally noticed off-flavors connected to oxidation from the illuminated samples. In the sensory evaluation, we focused on the effect at 525 nm, which was observed in all the dairy products. The experimental design also allowed us to investigate whether it was possible to correlate sensory description with the observed gradients in fluorescence.
The sensory panel could indeed register a gradient in oxidized odor and flavor for both cream cheeses. Figure 9
shows the mean sensory scores for these properties moving inwards in the cheese. The results indicate that light-induced oxidation propagated somewhat further into the 7-d cheese compared with the 4-d cheese, and that the sensory scores were also higher until reaching a minimum at approximately 7.5 mm. From 7.5 to 12.5 mm, the sensory scores leveled out, indicating that the cheese at this point and deeper was "fresh." Standard deviation for each measurement is not included in the curves, as the variation between judges was relatively large. For both oxidized flavor and odor, there was no significant difference between the three upper layers (0 to 5 mm); however, these layers had significantly higher scores compared with the three lower layers (7.5 to 12.5 mm). The same results applied for the attributes of total odor and total flavor.
|
|
|
A significant reduction in fluorescence intensity at approximately 525 nm, and a corresponding increase in the region 415 to 490 nm, as a result of illumination. This effect applied to all the products tested and can probably be ascribed to photodegradation of riboflavin.
Variation in two smaller peaks at approximately 620 and 630 nm seems to be an interaction effect between exposure to light and air.
A very pronounced interaction effect between light and air producing intense blue fluorescence and off-flavors on Jarlsberg cheese.
A close correlation between fluorescence spectra and sensory measured off-flavors.
It was also shown that simple image analysis can reveal how far into the product the light-induced oxidation propagates. With this technique one can also effectively visualize and study the kinetics of this process in different products.
The present study has revealed some interesting properties of solid sample fluorescence from dairy products. The consistent results from the different products together with high correlations with sensory analysis make this detection method very promising. Methods to measure light-induced oxidation in dairy products have been sought, but currently no satisfactory techniques are available (Kristensen et al., 2000). This method might fulfill some of the needs in that respect.
The experiments also leave several unanswered questions. To verify the hypothesis that we are indeed measuring the degree of light-induced degradation of riboflavin careful reference analyses should be performed. If verified, the method could probably be used for rapid quantification of riboflavin content in foods. The origin and impact of the peaks at 620 to 630 nm should be elucidated. The sensitivity of fluorescence with regard to time/intensity of light and oxygen exposure, as well as to sensory properties should also be investigated. Preliminary measurements at our lab (not yet published) suggest that cheese under normal light exposure after 1 d of storage can be distinguished from cheese stored in the dark.
The novel use of solid sample fluorescence spectroscopy should certainly be explored further, since the method is rapid, requires no sample preparation, and is easily automated. Finally, we note that the optical measurements performed in this study were technically not very advanced. Therefore, it should be easy to implement a dedicated, simpler system to reduce cost.
| CONCLUSIONS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Solid-sample fluorescence can be used as a nondestructive and rapid tool to measure the degree of light-induced degradation of riboflavin in dairy products.
Images of fluorescence can be used to visualize the intensity and propagation of this process.
Solid-sample fluorescence can be used as a nondestructive and rapid tool to measure sensory properties connected to storage of dairy products.
Since light catalyzed degradation of riboflavin is a precursor for off-flavors, the method might be capable of detecting early oxidation in dairy products.
The simplicity and rapidity of the method offer rich opportunities for efficient evaluation of factors affecting light-induced oxidation in dairy products, such as packaging materials, light sources, exposure time, and temperature.
| ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Received for publication December 17, 2001. Accepted for publication January 30, 2002.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
A. Veberg, E. Olsen, A. N. Nilsen, and J. P. Wold Front-Face Fluorescence Measurement of Photosensitizers and Lipid Oxidation Products During the Photooxidation of Butter J Dairy Sci, May 1, 2007; 90(5): 2189 - 2199. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
X. Liu and L. E. Metzger Application of Fluorescence Spectroscopy for Monitoring Changes in Nonfat Dry Milk During Storage J Dairy Sci, January 1, 2007; 90(1): 24 - 37. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
E. Miquel Becker, J. Christensen, C. S. Frederiksen, and V. K. Haugaard Front-Face Fluorescence Spectroscopy and Chemometrics in Analysis of Yogurt: Rapid Analysis of Riboflavin J Dairy Sci, August 1, 2003; 86(8): 2508 - 2515. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. Christensen, V. T. Povlsen, and J. Sorensen Application of Fluorescence Spectroscopy and Chemometrics in the Evaluation of Processed Cheese During Storage J Dairy Sci, April 1, 2003; 86(4): 1101 - 1107. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |